Timothy Moerland, explaining that he was barred from the class upon Downie’s request. Upon his refusal to admit fault and agree to the disciplinary terms, Ingle received a letter from Provost Dr.
Alison downie professor free#
It is my belief that the instructor’s decision to file these sanctions is an attempt to bully me into redacting my views, making it a matter of free speech,” Ingle wrote in his Facebook post, which he provided to TheDCNF. Rather, I objected to its misuse as hard evidence to support the ‘reality’ of phenomena that are not only a matter of opinion, but also empirically unsupported (wage gap statistics). “I did not object to the views of the speaker (Paula Stone).
Ingle refused to sign the documents, alleging that Downie’s account of the incident included false statements and claims that he never made. The documents described Ingle’s alleged violation and the disciplinary terms to which Downie asked Ingle to agree. Ingle told TheDCNF that the class continued without disruption after he spoke out, but Downie met with him the following day to give him an Academic Integrity Referral Form and Documented Agreement. Ingle has since deleted the Facebook post in accordance with advice from his legal counsel. Ingle told Campus Reform that Downie tried to silence him “because I am not a woman.” Ingle refused to be deterred, however, and according to the Facebook post “took this opportunity to point out the official view of biologists who claim there are only two biological genders” and disputed the gender wage gap. Ingle told TheDCNF that he waited for up to a minute, during which time no student spoke, before speaking out and giving what he described as a “passionate” rebuttal of the premise of Downie’s proposed discussion. Male students were, according to Ingle, instructed to remain silent until the female students had their chance to speak. Ingle also alleged that Downie opened up the class discussion only to the female students. Please Support The Stream: Equipping Christians to Think Clearly About the Political, Economic and Moral Issues of Our Day. “Learning is an active, sometimes downright uncomfortable and difficult process which requires sustained, committed involvement in a supportive (and, I hope fun) respectful atmosphere….In my view, if a course (or research) is not challenging, even disruptive in some ways, it is not likely to be particularly rewarding,” Downie wrote.ĭownie clarified further down in the document that students can cultivate a respectful atmosphere by seriously engaging with the course material through analysis and critique based on a thorough understanding of the selected author’s or speaker’s position. The course’s syllabus says the class “traces historical developments and contemporary debates in Christian understanding of the human, sin, and salvation” and that students will gain an understanding of these subjects by engaging with and discussing “a range of Christian perspectives.”ĭownie also wrote in the course’s “Classroom Policies and Expectations” that students are expected to be active participants in each session. The professor made it very clear that these things (White male privilege, mainsplaining, etc.) were … well, she seemed to me that she made it clear that they were a reality and not part of an ongoing discussion,” Ingle told TheDCNF. “I protested to the use of anecdotal evidence to then start a discussion and trying to reference the material or the speaker’s account as if they were facts.
Ingle told TheDCNF that he objected to the discussion because Downie allegedly prompted the class to talk about “the reality of white male privilege,” systemic male sexism, and concepts like “mansplaining” based on Williams’ talk. 28 class discussion based on a Ted Talk by Paula Stone Williams, who is a transgender woman. Alison Downie’s attempt to have him permanently removed from a class called “Special Topics In Christianity: Self, Sin, And Salvation.”ĭownie sanctioned Ingle and tried to have him barred from the class for challenging the premise of a Feb. Lake Ingle, an Indiana University senior, told The Daily Caller News Foundation that he appeared before the university’s Academic Integrity Board (AIB) on March 9 to dispute Dr. An Indiana University Pennsylvania professor barred one of her students from a class on Christianity for refusing to apologize for challenging transgender and feminist arguments.
0 kommentar(er)
